The
team that brought us A Beautiful Mind several years ago - director
Ron Howard, screenwriter Akiva Goldsman and actor Russell Crowe - are
back with another biopic. Cinderella Man is the story of James
J. Braddock, an Irish fighter who lost it all during the Great Depression
but rose again to become a champion. It's a true Cinderella story.
Cinderella Man begins just before the Stock Market Crash of 1929.
James Braddock (Russell Crowe) is winning and on top of the world with
his happy marriage to Mae (Renee Zellweger) and their beautiful home
- but all that is about to change. Braddock, like most, is hit hard
by the Great Depression and several years later, the Braddock's are
living in a basement apartment with no heat. Work on the docks is meager
and due to a broken hand and run of bad luck his fighting career is
over. But friend and former manager Joe Gould (Paul Giamatti) gets him
one small fight. To everyone's surprise, Braddock wins. Even more surprisingly,
he continues to win. Eventually, he's considered for the title shot
against the deadly Max Baer (Craig Bierko) (who really did kill two
men in the ring).
Of all the sports, boxing lends itself to some of the best movies: Raging
Bull, Rocky, and Million Dollar Baby. I think because
it's an individual sport. There isn't a team with a multitude of subplots
to muddle the story. With boxing, it is the singular story of the singular
effort of one man (or woman) entering the ring and facing one other
man (or woman). It's simple. It's straightforward. It's dramatic. It's
action. In Cinderella Man that one man, James J. Braddock enters
the ring fighting for his dignity and his humanity during a time when
those things were in short supply.
During the fight sequences, I looked around and the audience was on
the edge of their seats, literally. There were random cheers and outbreaks
of applause, always a good sign. But the scene that had the most impact
for me didn't take place in the ring. Braddock, facing a winter with
no heat, goes with hat in hand, to his old boxing cronies and begs for
the money he needs to pay the heating bill. Braddock is fighting for
his family and his dignity takes the KO. It's one of those scenes that
just sticks with you.
As far as performances, Russell Crowe does what he does best, the introverted,
intense man who reaches down within himself and, through nothing but
sheer resolve, beats the odds. Crowe could receive another Oscar nomination
for this one. So could Paul Giamatti as Joe Gould, Braddock's manager
and friend. Who doesn't fare so well in my estimation is Renee Zellweger.
She's not bad but her co-stars (Crowe and Giamatti) brought their Oscar-caliber
game and hers just isn't up to snuff. In her defense, the character
of Mae has two basic modes, doting on her husband and worry about her
husband and family.
At an indulgent two and a half hours, Cinderella Man could have
been a little tighter. But Howard does an amazing job capturing the
details of Depression era New York and New Jersey. He also gives the
film a nostalgic and opulent look by filming in beautiful warm sepia
tones. He's created a movie with a real authentic feel.
While
not quite a dramatic TKO, Cinderella Man definitely wins by unanimous
decision.
|